Ten years in the past, I employed an editor to grade my weblog posts as an AP English instructor would possibly. Yesterday, I requested an AI to do the identical factor.
The decision? A strong B-.
Claude’s Scorecard
Grade: B-
Strengths:
The piece demonstrates a transparent understanding of advanced technical ideas and makes an attempt to make them accessible to a normal viewers. The creator’s private connection to deep studying by means of graduate college research provides authenticity and historic perspective. This human contact helps floor the technical materials in lived expertise.
Areas for Enchancment:
Construction & Circulation (C+)
Language & Fashion (B-)
Growth of Concepts (B)
Voice & Tone (B)
Technical Integration (B+)
Studying the suggestions triggered two feelings : nostalgia for Mr. Dunn’s legendary pink pen in AP English & a thrill for concrete suggestions to strengthen the piece.
Again & forth, I iterated with Claude, till I floor the piece to an A-. Nonetheless not perfection, however a reminder that clear writing calls for relentless revision and an openness to criticism – classes Mr. Dunn taught me way back.
In enterprise, we don’t usually obtain the relentless teaching of a terrific instructor, however with AI, the pink pen is only a mouse click on away.
